• Home
  • About
  • Store
  • -->
 
Click here to subscribe to the RSS Feed in your favorite feed reader
 
 
 
Click here to have new posts sent straight to your email

theFiver.net

The Top 5 Blog

August 12th, 2009

...now browsing by day

 

You say you want a revolution

Wednesday, August 12th, 2009

“Your revolution is over! Condolences! The bums lost!”

— The Big Lebowski

My friend Andrew recently touched on something that has bothered me for years, but have I never been able to properly express. In commenting on Rolling Stone’s 100 greatest guitarist list, Andrew wrote:

“As usual, these lists end up nothing more than ways to piss people off and drive page hits/ad revenue. Rolling Stone has been irrelevant for decades now, and this is another great excuse to pander to the ‘I survived the 60s, so your music sucks, man!’ demographic, with a few oddly-chosen ringers to appear ‘hip’ and ‘with it’ (say in a Dr. Evil voice for maximum effect) to Generation X.”

There is something of a selfish streak in the Boomer demographic Andrew mentions, but I’m not entirely sure they’ve earned the right to be selfish.

The greatest generation went through hell and back, overcoming the worst economic times of the 20th century before defeating the greatest evil of the same 100 years. The boomers had their share of strife to overcome – civil rights, Vietnam. The difference is, the generation that fought the Depression and World War II managed to do it without self-agrandizment. They went on give everything to their children. For the boomers, their favorite subject is themselves. And they don’t let you forget it.

Two of America’s most popular writers, Stephen King and Dave Barry, are boomers, and you don’t have to read between the lines to see the importance they place on their generation. King’s fiction often takes place in the ’50s and ’60s. In “The Body,” “It,” or the stories of “Hearts In Atlantis” King’s reflection of that era has a guild that shines with a force that greatly overshadows plot. Reading “It” is like being trapped in an episode of The Wonder Years, only with a killer clown.

Barry, however, is worse in “Dave Barry Turns 50.” In that book, humorist gives readers a year-by-year account of history from 1947 before he gets bored by 1974. For him, it’s as though history stops there, and that’s just as well. Barry writes: “what, really, is the difference between, say, 1985 and 1987?”

OK, in ‘85, Reagan is sworn in for a second term, the first artificial heart recipient leaves the hospital, the FDA apporves a blood test for AIDS, Gorbachev becomes General Secretary of the Soviets, WrestleMania, South Africa ends a ban on interracial marriage, Coke brings out New Coke, TWA flight 487 is hijacked by Hezbollah, Route 66 (that old Boomer legend) is decommissioned, Christa McAulife is chosen to fly aboard Challenger, the wreck of the Titanic is discovered, Nintendo makes its US debut as does Calvin and Hobbes, Windows 1.0 is unleashed on an unsuspecting world, the Ford Taurus debuts, John Gotti becomes head of the New York Mafia, and widespread famine continues to wreak havoc in Ethiopia.

In 1987: Arehta Franklin becomes the first woman inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Reagan addresses Iran-Contra, U2 releases “The Joshua Tree,” USS Stark is attacked by Iraqi missiles, WrestleMainia III shatters attendance records, The Simpsons debut on the Tracy Ullman Show, Jim Bakker defrocked, Gary Hart drops out of the Democratic primary because he was porking Donna Rice, Margaret Thatcher wins a third term, Reagan to Gorby: “Tear down this wall,” world population reaches 5 billion, the Dow closes above 2,500, G’N'R debuts “Appetite for Destruction,” Hungerford massacre, Pat Robertson and Jesse Jackson run for President, the first National Coming Out Day, baby Jessica falls down a well, Black Monday, US blows up Iranian oil platforms in the Persian Gulf, NASA awards contracts for the Freedom space station (later becomes International Space Station), Chunnel construction starts, Hustler v Falwell, Prozac hits US shelves, first version of Photoshop, and a freaking squirrel closes the NYSE when it borrows through a phone line.

That’s the fucking difference.

These facts can be found on Wikipedia or whatever means of research you choose, you just need to look beyond your own generational selfishness and make the effort. Meanwhile, so-called Gens X and Y are still dealing with the world inherited us: our own Vietnam (Iraq), global warming, AIDS, the worst recession since the Depression, Gitmo …

I can’t believe you started the fire.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Share/Bookmark

Posted in Editorial | No Responses »

Top 5 “what the hell were they thinking?!” moments on Rolling Stone’s 100 Greatest Guitarists of All Time

Wednesday, August 12th, 2009

disc

Rolling Stone has listed what it claims are “The 100 Greatest Guitarists Of All Time.” Rather than come up with the definitive list, however, the article simply fans the flames of a long-running debate.

Many music critics would say that sound and inventiveness trumps technique and skill.  Serious musicians could counter that even if you stun listeners across the nation with your songs, it doesn’t mean your playing is any good, never mind sophisticated.

The RS list appears to lean toward the former argument. That’s fine, but in reading its list, one can’t help but feel mislead. If they called this list “100 Great Artists Whose Guitar Is Their Primary Instrument,” then, yeah, you could get behind that. But to give props to Soundgarden’s Kim Thayil because he used dropped-D tuning, but exclude technically superior musicians like Eric Johnson and Alex Lifeson … that just seems wrong.

One thing is for certain; Rolling Stone’s list leaves a lot of head-scratching.

Top 5 “what the hell were they thinking?!” moments on Rolling Stone’s 100 Greatest Guitarists of All Time:


1. Eric Clapton

clapton

No. Sorry. He’s not the fourth greatest guitarist of all time. I’m not even sure if he’s the fortieth. Yes, he’s incredibly popular; yes, he’s been around for a bit; yes, he deserves a huge thanks for giving the blues a British renaissance; and yes, the baby boomers love him. But as my old guitar teacher once said, any kid on the street corner can play his licks. The pentatonic scale is just not that hard. If he’s “God,” then my dad’s God … and he’s not.

2. Kurt Cobain

cobain


Cobain helped to give the music industry an enema just when its hair band-impacted bowels needed it, and we’re all better off for that. But Cobain was not that great of a guitarist, he just wasn’t it. If you need to recognize a guitarist representing the early ’90s alternative/grunge music, why not Pearl Jam’s Mike McCready?

3. Johnny Ramone

Ramone


Punk is a good and almost necessary form of music. But its very nature shuns the technical know-how of its contemporaries such as prog-rock. The Ramones is New York punk through and through, but you didn’t go to CBGB to hear an exercise on symmetrical augmented scales.

4. Keith Richards

KeithRichards


One of the most overrated guitarists from the world’s biggest overrated band. The Rolling Stones did not do much to innovate. They came along at the right time, tweaking the Beatles sound with a bit more sex and drugs, and most of them had the good fortune to stick together and not die. Richards is a decent guitarist, but he’s not one of the all-time greatest.

5. Neil Young

young


As a singer-song writer, he’s fine. But like Cobain, he’s simply not that great of a guitarist. If you want to talk musicianship with a flair for songwriting, give me Paul Simon any day of the week.

Runners up: George Harrison (#21); The Edge (#24); Ron Asheton (#29); Tom Morello (#26); John Fogerty (#40); Clarence White (#41); Joni Mitchell (#72); Joan Jett (#87).

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Share/Bookmark

Posted in Top 5 | 3 Responses »
Tags: Alex Lifeson, CBGB, Clarence White, Cream, Credence Clearwater Revival, Derek and the Dominos, Eric Clapton, Eric Johnson, George Harrison, Joan Jett, John Fogerty, Johnny Ramone, Jonie Mitchell, Keith Richards, Kim Thayil, Kurt Cobain, Mike McCready, Neil Young, Nirvana, Paul Simon, Pearl Jam, Rage Against The Machine, Rolling Stone, Rolling Stones, Ron Asheton, Rush, Soundgarden, The Beatles, The Byrds, The Edge, The Ramones, Tom Morello, U2, Yardbirds

  • Google
    Custom Search
  • About me
    • My bio
    • My portfolio
  • Blogroll
    • Bed Time Movies
    • Breaking Even
    • Isn't the Light OK?
    • The Kate of All Trades
  • Get involved
    • Protect Maine Equality
  • Links
    • Become a fan on Facebook
    • Follow on Twitter
    • TheFiver Online Store
  • Recent Posts
    • TheFiver to return Spring 2010
    • PerformanceKlok: Yeeeeeeah!
    • PerformanceKlok: What you say about his compan-whatnow?
    • SpektorKlok
    • PerformanceKlok: Shining like a national guitar
  • Recent Comments
    • Leah on PerformanceKlok: What you say about his compan-whatnow?
    • Leah on Top 5 songs used in iTunes commercials
    • John on For Leah, on her birthday – PerformanceKlok special edition
    • Leah on For Leah, on her birthday – PerformanceKlok special edition
    • Leah on Top 5 artists everyone likes but me
  • Categories
    • Blog news
    • Concert Report
    • Duets Week
    • Editorial
    • Film week
    • Hate Week
    • Newsbit
    • PerformanceKlok
    • Song title idea of the day
    • Top 5
    • Uncategorized
  • Pages
    • About
    • Bio
    • Store
  •  
    August 2009
    M T W T F S S
    « Jul   Sep »
     12
    3456789
    10111213141516
    17181920212223
    24252627282930
    31  
  • Meta
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org
  • Archives
    • December 2009 (2)
    • November 2009 (13)
    • October 2009 (27)
    • September 2009 (30)
    • August 2009 (28)
    • July 2009 (33)
    • June 2009 (28)

Powered by WordPress | © 2010 theFiver.net | A WPHackr Experience